“We fully support a greater focus on vocational and technical education alongside the existing high academic standards in our schools and colleges, and with the importance of great work experience opportunities and careers guidance. We also agree with the crucial significance of good attendance. It is important to understand that schools and colleges already strive to provide their pupils and students with the best possible preparation for life and often have to do so within the context of lack of funding, staffing, time, and an accountability system which penalises rather than supports them. We also agree with the vital importance of literacy and numeracy as the foundational skills which are crucial to education and life opportunities.
“However, it is disappointing to see how quickly the report defaults to the usual mishmash of targets, tests, and new accountability measures which are a hallmark of many other reports over recent years. Adding a new ready-for-work standard into school performance measures and Ofsted inspections will create yet more pressure on a system which is already overwhelmed with expectations and which is simply not resourced to deliver a whole new tier of requirements. If the government intends to do this then it must come up with a realistic plan and the funding to enable schools to deliver this expectation.
“A new statutory key stage 3 writing, numeracy, and oracy check also creates another set of requirements which will detract from curriculum time in already overcrowded timetables. We would question what purpose is served by introducing more assessment. Substantially raising targets for school preparedness and the proportion of 11-year-olds reaching the expected standard is laudable and it is right to be ambitious. But we do need a practical plan of how we are going to actually do this given that many of the factors which affect educational development lie in wider socio-economic challenges.
“We are pleased to see the recognition that colleges need additional investment. They have been treated as a Cinderella service for far too long despite their critical role in providing the technical skills base for the nation. We welcome the specific funding proposals made in the report, including the extension of funding for care-experienced young people, but we would like to see this taken further with the creation of a 16-19 student premium to provide additional support for all disadvantaged learners. We are also concerned about the proposal to create a new work readiness performance measure for colleges. Similarly to schools, they already face a huge number of expectations, and if anything, have even less funding with which to deliver them.
“We look forward to discussing the detail of these proposals with the government and will be calling on ministers to ensure that the implementation of any new changes is assessed against the funding and workforce capacity required to deliver them.”